Why veterans matter.

Pharsalus, the battle fought on this day in 48 BC was the defining moment in the careers of both Julius Caesar and Pompey the Great. Pompey was the great man in Rome for as long as most people could remember. He came to attenion serving under his father at the age of 16 in the Social war. A hayseed from Picenum his father Gnaeus Pompeius Strabo was a “new man”, what we would today call “new money”. Not proper Roman stock. But he was rich and could afford to put a legion behind his son.

By 83 BC Pompey was able to support Sulla in the Civil War against the Marian faction. Marius was married to Julia, Caesar’s aunt. Sulla famously said he saw many a Marius in Caesar. So Pompey and Caesar began their careers on opposite sides.

Pompey styled himself “Magnus” with youthful bravado aged only 24, but he had the chutzpah to do it. He bypassed the cursus honorum and was elected consul three times. He also celebrated three triumphs. He brought the messy and drawn out Sertorian rebellion to a conclusion, earning wealthy Spanish clients along the way. He famously cleared the Mediterranean of pirates, securing an unprecedented pro-consular authority to the coastlines of every maritime province to succeed. More clients fell into his lap.

He then went to the wealthy East, defeated Mithridates, and – you guessed it – more clients. He was fabulously wealthy. Almost as wealthy as Marcus Crassus. The first man in Rome. But his settlement of clients in the East relied on some treaties he had agreed with local rulers. On his return to Rome he found himself opposed by the conservative faction of the Senate.

From stage left stepped an unlikely ally; Julius Caesar. You will have your treaties if I can have my Consulship! And to seal the deal Caesar offered his daughters hand. The old man was smitten by the beatiful Julia and fell madly in love. With Crassus the three formed the first Triumvirate.

It was the death of Julia that led to the division between Caesar and Pompey. The Optimates of the Senate, those who originally opposed his treaties in the East, leaped on the chance to bring Pompey to their camp. They found him a new wife and a gang of new friends and gave him an army to oppose Caesar who had just crossed the Rubicon at the head of his veteran legions.

Pompey found himself in command of an army larger than Caesars, but they were green men. So he moved south and shipped them to Greece for training. Caesar, lacking a navy, could not follow. Instead he reversed course and eliminated the Pompeian forces in Hispania province, securing his back in the kind of clever strategy he might have learned from Pompey himself.

In January 48 BC Caesar at last managed to ship seven legions to modern day Albania. Pompey rapidly moved to besiege him in an attempt to starve him into submission. The arrival of Mark Anthony with four legions of reinforcements in March forced Pompey to withdraw. So it was not until August that the armies met.

Pompey held the high ground. He had one flank anchored on a river. He commanded over 40,000 men and 6,000 cavalry. Caesar was at the bottom of a hill in marshy land with his 22,000 men and 1,000 cavalry. But Caesar had hard fought battle trained veterans, and that is often the difference.

Pompey’s plan was simple, he positioned his infantry on the top of the hill in deep lines and all they had to do was hold on against an inferior infantry force. Hold the line, while with his massive superiority in cavalry he would sweep around Caesars right flank and roll up his line, driving Caesars men into the river.

Caesar saw what Pompey’s plan was and thinned his left flank, bringing as many men as he could to support his favourite legion the Legio X under his command on the right flank.

On his right Pompey ordered his men to hold the hilltop and not advance against the caesarian legions led by Mark Anthony. Poorly trained troops fall apart when they march, so it was safer to hold them steady. This allowed Anthony to climb the hill, and then order his men to rest and regroup before advancing further. If Pompey had experienced men they would have smashed the thinned out left wing of Caesar’s army at this point.

When Pompey’s cavalry charged Caesars right wing he drove off the caesarian cavalry as expected. But now Caesar unleashed his surprised weapon. The troops he had thinned from his left flank had been formed up secretly behind his three files on the right wing. They were now instructed to charge into the Pompeian cavalry and use their javelins as spears to unseat the horsemen. The result was chaos. Pompey’s cavalry lost all their impetus and were driven into a confused mess.

Caesar’s cavalry, who had withdrawn in good order, now wheeled about, reformed and charged into Pompey’s cavalry, driving them off the field of battle.

Now Pompey’s left wing was completely exposed to the mighty Legio X and the reinforcements from the rest of the field. They fell like a hammer on the inexperienced Pompeian right wing.

The day was over and Pompey knew it. He fled the field, south to find a ship to take him to Egypt, where he met a grizly end. Beheaded by a Roman Officer serving with the Egyptians who thought the head of Caesar’s old friend would please the victor. Nothing could be farther from the truth. Caesar wept.

Pharsalia (excerpt) ; by Lucan

No single death deserves its own lament,
no time to mourn the individual.
Pharsalus was unlike the former battles’
catastrophes. There Rome fell with men’s fates,
here with entire peoples’. Soldiers died there
but here whole nations perished. Here blood streamed
from Greek, Assyrian and Pontic veins,
which might have congealed on the field in one
cross-ethnic scab, but for a huge deluge
of Roman gore.

In that unholy battle
upon the stinking plains of Thessaly,
the peoples all sustained a deeper wound
than their own era could endure. Much more
than life and safety were lost there. We were
made prostrate for eternity. Every age
that suffers slavery fell to those swords.

But what did grandsons and great-grandsons do
to deserve birth in an autocracy?
Were ours the blades that fell with fear? Did we
snivel behind our shields and hide our throats?
The penalty of others’ cowardice
is hung around our necks today.

O Fortune,
since then you’ve only given us more tyrants!
Why not at least give us a chance to fight?

-=o0o=-

This site is available for free and I make no money from any ads you see here. If you would like to show your appreciation feel free to leave a comment or you can buy me a coffee! http://buymeacoffee.com/DonalClancy

Las Trece Rosas

History is often at variance with reality and a good example of this is the history of the Spanish Civil War. On paper the civil war ended on April 1st 1939. In reality the Civil War raged on for many years. Elements of the Spanish Maquis remained active into the 1960’s. Spain, the tourism capital of Europe, was not a tourist destination in the Francoist era. It was known to be a brutal conservative police state.

Today is the anniversary of Las Trece Rosas, the 13 roses. These were 13 young women, youth activists from Madrid who were members of Communist and Socialist youth organisations. They were identifed when the leader of their organization cracked under torture and gave up the names of members. The girls, aged from 18 to 29 were brutalised, raped and tortured and on August 5th, 1939 were driven from the Ventas prison to the wall of the East Cemetery in Madrid. They were put against the wall and shot by a Francoist firing squad.

The fate of Las Trece Rosas has become a trigger issue in Spanish politics in the recent elections. As the Conservative far right VOX party has risen in profile the socialists are labelling them the successors of the oppressive Francoist regime and are pinning the blame on them for the actions at the end of the civil war.

Civil wars are brutal affairs. They seldom truly end until all the combatants pass away and the hidden weapons succumb to rust. Opportunists use family loyalties to their advantage once they find themselves on the winning side. If you always coveted your neighbours fields there is no better time to rat him out. This has been the case all through history. In ancient Rome the Marian and Sullan factions famously used proscription lists to cull their opposition and seize their lands, homes and possessions. If you needed some ready cash you just needed to point the finger at a rich man with uncertain loyalties.

Here in Ireland our civil war ended on May 24th 1923. It took until the 2020 general election before the political parties that represented the opposing sides could eventually sit at the same table.

The Good Friday Agreement was signed in 1998 in Northern Ireland. The timetable for unification of the Republic and Northern Ireland might be planned around the year 2090 when residual tensions have subsided and a third generation has grown up in peace.

O, Gather Me the Rose; by William Ernest Henley

O, gather me the rose, the rose,
while yet in flower we find it,
for summer smiles, but summer goes,
and winter waits behind it!

For with the dream foregone, foregone,
the deed forborne for ever,
the worm, regret, will canker on,
and time will turn him never.

So well it were to love, my love,
and cheat of any laughter
the death beneath us and above,
the dark before and after.

The myrtle and the rose, the rose,
the sunshine and the swallow,
the dream that comes, the wish that goes,
the memories that follow!

-=o0o=-

This site is available for free and I make no money from any ads you see here. If you would like to show your appreciation feel free to leave a comment or you can buy me a coffee! http://buymeacoffee.com/DonalClancy

Wu of Han

Between the second and first centuries BC, while the cracks in the fabric of the Roman Republic that would become its death knell were forming Han China enjoyed a golden age. Wu of Han was a most unlikely candidate to ascend the Dragon Throne as the Son of Heaven.

Born the 11th son of Emperor Jing of Han. Only 15 when he was crowned, he reigned for an incredible 54 years. Under his rule Han China flowered as a civilization. He kept the steppe tribes on the steppes. He extended the empire into Korea in the West, Vietnam in the South and to its furthest extent West along the Silk Roads to the Fergana Valley in Khorasan. Music, art, and poetry all flourished.

In the far west the Romans were clubbing the brothers Gracchi to death for suggesting land reform. Marius reformed the legions to defend Rome from the Cimbri and Teutones. Rome fought the social war with its Italian neighbours and then Marius and Sulla scrapped it out in a brutal civil war marked by proscription lists, property seizures and murders disguised as executions.

Sadly the golden reign of Emperor Wu descended into horror in his final years. It often takes heavy spending to maintain long term peace. Spending requires heavy taxation. The end of his reign was marked by peasant revolts against taxes that were funnelled into increasingly megalomaniacal vanity projects. The Emperor became paranoid and began to imprison, torture and execute entire clans of nobles accused of witchcraft. He ended up in conflict with his own son the Crown Prince who died, along with his sons, when besieged by soldiers motivated by offers of reward. A sad end to one of the greatest reigns in history.

The Cabbage Farmer

Image result for gone to grow cabbages sign

Emperor Diocletian began his reign as ruler of Rome on November 20th 284 AD.  In 305 AD he did the unthinkable for a Roman Emperor; he retired.  He expressed a desire to live in his estate and grow cabbages.  He was very proud of his cabbages.  The modern Croatian town of Split is centred on the villa of Diocletian.

Diocletian rose to power in the “Crisis of the 3rd Century” when Rome was falling apart as one general after another competed for the top job.  Diocletian established a system called the Tetrarchy, four rulers, as a means to stabilise the empire.

Both Eastern and Western Empire had a senior Augustus and a junior Caesar.  His new system worked successfully until the rise of Constantine the Great, who became another Augustus, founding New Rome in Byzantium, renamed Constantinople, and now Istanbul.

Diocletian was the only Emperor I know of to retire.  Emperors died in office, were assasinated or forced to abdicate.  The only other Roman I can think of who retired, without being forced to leave, was Sulla.  In 78 BC Lucius Cornelius Sulla astoundingly retired from his Lifetime Dictatorship to write his memoirs and live a life of luxury on his country estate.  His departure from power is celebrated as his moment of ultimate glory in the verse from Byron below.

That Diocletian retired was a mark of his commitment to peaceful succession.  The ultimate failure of his system, within mere decades, underlines how difficult it is to have power hungry leaders give up the reins of power.  Democratic systems succeed only if they prevent a return to family dynasties.

Donald Trump likes to float the notion, from time to time, of a presidency for life.  Vladimir Putin has gone further and established one using some smoke and mirrors.  In North Korea the cult of the leader has entirely undermined socialist principles of meritocracy by establishing a 3 generation dynastic rule.

Great leaders are great until they go bad, and then they become really terrible.  Limit your leaders.  Give them a maximum time limit.  They may suggest a candidate to follow them, but don’t let them choose one.

From the “Ode to Napoleon Buonoparte”; by George Gordan, Lord Byron

VII

The Roman, when his burning heart
was slaked with blood of Rome,
threw down the dagger — dared depart,
in savage grandeur, home —
he dared depart in utter scorn
of men that such a yoke had borne,
yet left him such a doom!
His only glory was that hour
of self-upheld abandon’d power.

-=o0o=-

Hope you enjoyed this post. My site is free and open access. I make no money from any ads you may see here. If you would like to show your appreciation you can buy me a coffee! http://buymeacoffee.com/DonalClancy

Biafra

Achebe

Chinua Achebe and the flag of Biafra

Biafra existed as a pre-colonial state in what is now the South-Eastern corner of modern day Nigeria.  It is the home in the majority of the Igbo tribe.

In 1960 Nigeria attained independence from the United Kingdom and became an independent nation formed artificially by the British from a hodge podge of different tribal areas.  In the North mainly Hausa and Fulani, Sahel region semi-nomadic pastoralists who are predominantly Muslims.  In the South the Yoruba in the West and the Igbo in the East, Christians living in Tropical Coastal regions.

Five years after independence the new “nation” descended into coup and counter-coup replete with proscriptions along the lines of what happened in Ancient Rome when Sulla and Marius battled for control of the city.  To destroy Igbo cohesion the federal government gerrymandered the tribal area to split voting power.  Biafra elected to secede from Nigeria.  But it happens to be the region that contains all the oil.

What followed was a genocidal war against the Igbo by the Nigerian Federal Forces, supported by the United Kingdom.  It is only now emerging from British State papers how deeply the oil interests of Shell and BP were served by the Labour Government of Harold Wilson.  British arms suppliers also had an interest in the war, on the Federal side.  The British helped to starve the Igbo into submission.  Over two million people died from starvation over a period of two and a half years from mid 1967 to January 1970.  That is a genocide very similar in size and scale to the Irish Potato Famine.

Médecines sans Frontiéres (MSF) was founded as a reaction to the suffering in Biafra.  The Irish Spiritan Father Aengus Finucane, a Catholic Priest, organised food flights into makeshift airstrips to relieve suffering.  He put together a relief airforce of superannuated cargo planes with volunteer pilots.  His efforts led to the creation of the charity “Concern Worldwide”.  As a child in school in Ireland the suffering of the Biafran Children was top of mind to me, a constant cause and the subject of much fundraising activity.

The father of modern African Writing, Chinua Achebe, was caught up in the political turmoil of that era, and is himself an Igbo.

He twice refused the Nigerian honour Commander of the Federal Republic, in 2004 and 2011, saying:  ” I have watched particularly the chaos in my own state of Anambra where a small clique of renegades, openly boasting its connections in high places, seems determined to turn my homeland into a bankrupt and lawless fiefdom. I am appalled by the brazenness of this clique and the silence, if not connivance, of the Presidency.”

On Nigerian Independence he “found that the independence this country was supposed to have won was totally without content … The old white master was still in power. He had got himself a bunch of black stooges to do his dirty work for a commission”

Today, Nov 16th is the birthday of Achebe, born 1930 and who died in 2013.

Non-commitment; by Chinua Achebe

Hurrah! to them who do nothing
see nothing feel nothing whose
hearts are fitted with prudence
like a diaphragm across
womb’s beckoning doorway to bar
the scandal of seminal rage. I’m
told the owl too wears wisdom
in a ring of defense round
each vulnerable eye securing it fast
against the darts of sight. Long ago
in the Middle East Pontius Pilate
openly washed involvement off his
white hands and became famous. (Of all
the Roman officials before him and after
who else is talked about
every Sunday in the Apostles’ Creed?) And
talking of apostles that other fellow
Judas wasn’t such a fool
either; though much maligned by
succeeding generations the fact remains
he alone in that motley crowd
had sense enough to tell a doomed
movement when he saw one
and get out quick, a nice little
packet bulging his coat pocket
into the bargain—sensible fellow.